The bright lights of a photoshoot flashbulb illuminated Erin Murphy, channeling her iconic TV mom over five decades after their time together on the classic sitcom Bewitched. In January 2026, the 61-year-old actress offered fans a nostalgic peek behind the scenes of a retro-inspired magazine shoot. Her bouffant hairdo, pearl earrings, and winged eye makeup transported viewers back to the magical world of the beloved show.
Murphy, who portrayed young witch Tabitha Stephens on Bewitched from 1966 to 1972 alongside Elizabeth Montgomery as her enchanting mother Samantha Stephens, shared the striking image on Facebook. Capturing her resemblance to Montgomery, Murphy playfully noted, “A magazine tried to make me look like Samantha on Bewitched. I guess not a huge stretch.”
The former child star’s photo sparked a buzz among fans, with many drawing comparisons between Murphy and Montgomery. Suggestions even arose for Murphy to reprise her role as a grown-up Tabitha in a potential Bewitched revival.
Reflecting on her time with Montgomery, Murphy recalled the actress’s maternal nature, reminiscing about the tender moments shared behind the scenes. Murphy also expressed her admiration for Montgomery’s transformation with makeup, noting how it enhanced her beauty in the eyes of a child.
Looking to the future, Murphy speculated on where Tabitha might be today, envisioning her as a successful, empowered woman unafraid to embrace her magical heritage. In an October 2025 interview with Remind Magazine, Murphy emphasized the freedom of choice and self-expression that she believes Tabitha’s generation embodies.
Through her timeless portrayal of Tabitha, Erin Murphy continues to captivate audiences with her enduring charm and grace. Her recent homage to Samantha on Bewitched serves as a playful reminder of the magic that captured hearts for generations.
Stay informed with the latest pop culture news and celebrity interviews by subscribing to Parade’s Daily newsletter.
Peace Nero is a writer and blogger who loves to explore different topics of self-development. She shares her personal experiences in order to help people discover their true purpose in life.