Under the bright lights of Broadway, 43 years ago today, a play made history for all the wrong reasons. On that fateful night of February 22, 1983, the curtain rose on the production of Moose Murders in New York City, only to fall again on the same evening. Hopes were high for this mystery comedy show, but alas, it was not to be.
Written by Arthur Bicknell, Moose Murders unfolded at the Eugene O’Neill Theatre, following the Holloway family’s misadventures at the “Wild Moose Lodge” in the Adirondack Mountains. Snowed in with a motley crew of characters, they decide to play a murder mystery game, leading to a series of unexpected twists and turns.
Prior to opening night, Moose Murders faced challenges behind the scenes. Originally starring Eve Arden, the lead actress abruptly departed due to what was described as “artistic differences.” However, it was later revealed that Arden struggled with remembering lines and executing blocking, prompting a last-minute replacement by Holland Taylor, who stepped into the role with mere days of preparation.
Despite its star-studded cast, including Holland Taylor, June Gable, and more, Moose Murders failed to impress critics and audiences alike. In a scathing review by Frank Rich for The New York Times, the play was likened to the Titanic disaster, with memorable reunions expected among those who bore witness.
With its sole performance on February 22 also marking its swan song, Moose Murders secured its place in theatrical history—an infamous footnote in the annals of Broadway lore. The curtain may have fallen, but the memory of this ill-fated production lingers on, a cautionary tale for future generations of theater enthusiasts.
Peace Nero is a writer and blogger who loves to explore different topics of self-development. She shares her personal experiences in order to help people discover their true purpose in life.