The winds of change are blowing for a beloved duo from Bachelor Nation. Joe Amabile, also known as “Grocery Store Joe,” and Serena Pitt have been the hosts of the Bachelor Happy Hour podcast for over two years. However, a recent teaser for an upcoming episode has left fans puzzled, hinting that this may be the end of the road for the pair and their podcast.
In the teaser posted on Instagram on January 12 for the episode airing on January 13, Amabile announces, “We are here with you guys one last time,” while Pitt looks on and laughs. The caption simply reads, “New year, new us.”
Fans, as well as some past Bachelor Happy Hour alums like Thomas Jacobs, expressed surprise and confusion at Amabile’s statement. Jacobs, who is married to former host Becca Kufrin, commented, “One last time?!” Other fans questioned the meaning behind the announcement.
Pitt and Amabile took over as co-hosts of Bachelor Happy Hour in June 2023, bringing their unique dynamic to the popular podcast. In a December 31 podcast episode, the couple reflected on the highlights of 2025 and shared their plans for 2026, without giving any indication that they would be stepping away from the podcast in the new year.
Pitt discussed 2025 as a “transitional” year for her, noting professional changes and the excitement of finally obtaining her Green Card. Amabile, on the other hand, admitted to finding the year quite stressful and anxiety-ridden.
Despite their hopes to “reap the benefits” of their decisions in 2026, the teaser for the January 13 episode of Bachelor Happy Hour suggests that something has changed. Fans are left wondering if the podcast has been canceled, if Pitt and Amabile are choosing to leave, or if they have been let go.
As answers begin to unfold, one thing is clear: the future of Bachelor Happy Hour is uncertain, and fans are eager to discover the next chapter in the lives of Joe Amabile and Serena Pitt.
Peace Nero is a writer and blogger who loves to explore different topics of self-development. She shares her personal experiences in order to help people discover their true purpose in life.