In a bizarre and disturbing case, a Colorado couple, James David Agnew and Suzanne Ruth Agnew, have been accused of living with their threesome partner’s corpse for a staggering 18 months. The gruesome discovery was made on June 19, 2025, when police were contacted by Robert O’Neill, who was concerned about the welfare of his brother, James O’Neill.
Upon arriving at the residence, officers were met by a man who identified himself as “James,” later revealed to be James Agnew. The couple initially gave conflicting stories about James O’Neill’s whereabouts, claiming he had left to live with a foreign woman he met online. However, the situation took a darker turn when Robert attempted to deposit an inheritance into James O’Neill’s account, prompting the Agnews to change their story.
Further investigations revealed that James Agnew had been using James O’Neill’s bank account and social security number, leading to his arrest on July 3, 2025. It was during this time that Suzanne Agnew allegedly confessed to police that James O’Neill’s body could be found inside the residence.
In a shocking revelation, Suzanne disclosed that she, James Agnew, and James O’Neill were involved in a threesome relationship. Tragically, O’Neill passed away in December 2023, and the couple decided not to report his death. Suzanne admitted to covering his body, leading to a chilling detail where their dogs began to chew on him.
James Agnew confessed to using O’Neill’s debit card and being aware of his passing. The couple had reportedly used a significant amount of O’Neill’s Social Security deposits for their own benefit. As a result, James and Suzanne Agnew are facing charges of tampering with a deceased human body, abuse of a corpse, theft, and unauthorized use of a financial transactional device.
Peace Nero is a writer and blogger who loves to explore different topics of self-development. She shares her personal experiences in order to help people discover their true purpose in life.