As Easter approaches, the air is filled with the scent of sweet treats and the colors of pastel baskets dotting the landscape. Plastic eggs, chocolate bunnies, and other classic Easter candies are part of the annual tradition. But each year, one confection emerges as the crowd favorite, the candy everyone seems to be reaching for.
New data from DoorDash offers a glimpse into the 2025 Easter season, revealing the top-selling candies that Americans are indulging in. From basket stuffers to egg hunt essentials, the numbers showcase the enduring love for classic Easter treats that are easy to share and enjoy.
Reese’s Pieces carrot gift bags took the top spot as the most-ordered Easter candy across the nation, as per DoorDash’s 2025 report. These festive plastic carrots filled with peanut butter candies are a natural choice for egg hunts and Easter baskets. The winning combination of chocolate and peanut butter continues to reign supreme, reminiscent of the same flavor pairing that dominates Halloween candy.
In addition to Reese’s Pieces carrots, other popular Easter treats made the list of the top 10 candies for the season. Palmer Double Crisp Lil’ Crispy Bunny, M&M’s Easter Bunny Cane, Lindt Gold Bunny, and Hershey’s Hershey-ets Easter Candy all found their way into the hearts (and baskets) of consumers.
The carrot-shaped Reese’s Pieces bags are particularly favored as basket stuffers due to their small size, vibrant colors, and easy sharing capabilities. Retailing at around $2.50 to $3 for a 2.2-ounce version, these treats are a budget-friendly option for those looking to spread some Easter cheer.
DoorDash’s data also sheds light on the springtime activities and trends that families are embracing. There has been a surge in purchases for DIY Easter baskets and supplies for spring crafts and activities. From storage baskets to chalk, food coloring, and arts and crafts materials, Americans are immersing themselves in the spirit of the holiday.
Despite the various activities and brunch offerings, candy remains at the heart of Easter celebrations. Reese’s Pieces carrot gift bags stand out as the favored treat this year, making their way into Easter baskets across the country. With easy accessibility at major retailers like Target, Walmart, Dollar General, and CVS, these peanut butter-filled delights are sure to bring joy to many this holiday season.
Peace Nero is a writer and blogger who loves to explore different topics of self-development. She shares her personal experiences in order to help people discover their true purpose in life.