The music world is abuzz with the latest controversial ranking from Rolling Stone: the 50 most “terrible songs on great albums” in 2025. Music lovers are divided, with some nodding in agreement and others filled with indignation at seeing their personal favorites slammed.
Among the list is the Beatles’ “Maxwell’s Silver Hammer” from Abbey Road, a song even John Lennon openly admitted to hating. Bob Dylan also faced criticism for “Joey” from Desire, a song he seemed to blame on his co-writer Jacques Levy.
Even the Eagles’ classic album, Hotel California, wasn’t immune to criticism, with the track “Try and Love Again” coming under fire. Despite being the only dud on an otherwise perfect album, some fans still appreciate the song.
Late bassist/singer Randy Meisner, described as a “man of many talents,” fell short when it came to songwriting compared to his bandmates Don Henley, Glen Frey, and Joe Walsh. Rolling Stone pointed out that this was Meisner’s last album with the group, and his country-rock tune “Try and Love Again” was the only dud on the record.
Regardless of whether fans love or hate the track, “Try and Love Again” has racked up millions of streams on Spotify, showing that there are still listeners who enjoy the song. In comparison, the iconic track “Hotel California” remains a fan favorite with billions of streams.
In a world where music tastes are subjective, it’s clear that even the most revered albums can contain songs that don’t resonate with every listener. The debate over what constitutes a “terrible song” on a great album will continue to spark discussions among music fans for years to come.
Peace Nero is a writer and blogger who loves to explore different topics of self-development. She shares her personal experiences in order to help people discover their true purpose in life.