In the world of classic television, the holiday spirit was alive and well on the set of the beloved sitcom Bewitched. During its eight-season run in the 1960s and early ‘70s, the show featured several Christmas-themed episodes that have remained fan favorites. One episode, in particular, titled “Sisters at Heart,” holds a special place in the heart of series star Elizabeth Montgomery.
In a recent interview, Erin Murphy, who played mini-witch Tabitha Stephens on the ABC sitcom, shared that “Sisters at Heart” was not only her favorite Christmas episode but also Elizabeth Montgomery’s favorite episode of the entire series. Airing on Christmas Eve in 1970, the episode tackled themes of prejudice and acceptance, earning a special Governor’s Emmy for its poignant message.
The memorable episode revolved around the friendship between Tabitha and her newfound friend Lisa Wilson, played by Venetta Rogers. The two girls faced discrimination from a bully who believed they couldn’t be sisters because of their different skin colors. Tabitha used her magic to unite them, but their troubles didn’t end there. A racist advertising client mistook Tabitha’s father, Darrin, played by Dick Sargent, for being married to Lisa’s mother, portrayed by Janee Michelle, causing further tension.
What makes “Sisters at Heart” even more remarkable is its origin story. Unlike other episodes written by the show’s regular staff, this particular script was the brainchild of a 10th-grade English class from Thomas Jefferson High School in Los Angeles. Their teacher, Marcella Saunders, challenged them to write an episode of Bewitched as a creative exercise, leading to a collaboration that captured the essence of the holiday spirit.
Despite the passage of more than 55 years, the names of all 26 students from Room 309 English class are still credited in the episode as “Story By,” a testament to the power of young voices. Erin Murphy fondly recalls the unique experience of having the entire class present for the table read, showcasing the impact of their work on the show’s legacy.
In today’s world, where conversations about social issues are more vital than ever, “Sisters at Heart” serves as a timeless reminder of the importance of unity and acceptance. Elizabeth Montgomery and the creative team behind Bewitched did not shy away from addressing challenging topics, leaving behind a legacy that continues to resonate with audiences. Through the lens of two young girls who proved that love knows no bounds, this episode remains a beautiful testament to the power of friendship and understanding.
Peace Nero is a writer and blogger who loves to explore different topics of self-development. She shares her personal experiences in order to help people discover their true purpose in life.